Subtleties of the new Caller Info Attributes in C# 5

UPDATE: Now that the Visual Studio 11 beta has shipped with this feature implemented, I wrote a separate blog post exploring how it actually behaves in these corner cases.

C# 5 is all about asynchronous programming.  However, in additional to the new async features, the C# team managed to slip in a much simpler feature: Caller Info Attributes.

Since C#’s inception, developers have asked for __LINE__ and __FILE__ macros like those in C and C++.  Since C# intentionally does not support macros, these requests have not been answered.  Until now.

C# 5 adds these features using attributes and optional parameters.  As Anders Hejlsberg presented at //Build/, you can write

public static void Log(string message,
    [CallerFilePath] string file = "",
    [CallerLineNumber] int line = 0,
    [CallerMemberName] string member = "")
    Console.WriteLine("{0}:{1} – {2}: {3}", 
                      file, line, member, message);


If this method is called in C# 5 without specifying the optional parameters, the compiler will insert the file name, line number, and containing member name instead of the default values.  If it’s called in older languages that don’t support optional parameters, those languages will pass the default values, like any other optional method.

These features look trivial at first glance.  However, like most features, they are actually more complicated to design in a solid and robust fashion.  Here are some of the less obvious issues that the C# team needed to deal with when creating this feature:

Disclaimer: I am basing these posts entirely on  logical deduction.  I do not have access to a specification or implementation of this feature; all I know is what Anders announced in his //Build/ presentation.  However, the C# team would have needed to somehow deal with each of thee issues.  Since these attributes are not yet supported by any public CTP, I can’t test my assumptions

To start with, they needed to create new compiler errors if the attribute is applied to an incorrectly-typed parameter, or a non-optional parameter.  Creating compiler errors is expensive; they need to be documented, tested, and localized into every language supported by C#.

The attributes should perhaps support nullable types, or parameter types with custom implicit conversions to int or string.  (especially long or short)

If a method with these attributes is called in an expression tree literal (a lambda expression converted to an Expression<TDelegate>), the compiler would need to insert ConstantExpressions with the actual line number or other info to pass as the parameter.

In addition to being supported in methods, the attributes should also be supported on parameters  for delegate types, allowing you to write

delegate void LinePrinter([CallerLineNumber] int line = 0);

LinePrinter printer = Console.WriteLine;

Each of the individual attributes also has subtle issues.

[CallerFilePath] seems fairly simple.  Any function call must happen in source code, in a source file that has a path.  However, it needs to take into account #line directives, so that, for example, it will work as expected in Razor views.  I don’t know what it does inside #line hidden, in which there isn’t a source file.

Next time: [CallerLineNumber]


The visibility of such information should be at the highest level. Lucinda

The above article is nice and interesting, thank you willing to share! Greetings success of admin Percetakan Murah Rawamangun Jakarta Timur wish you deign to visit my website, thank you :)

Information about Keylogger for Android from might be really useful to read for you and your friends. It's really important to know

It has become common for me to get good grades as soon as this site has asked me to do so, where they do any writing work in no time, with high quality and low prices, convenient for everyone.

These functions look trivial before everything glance. However, like most functions, they're in reality greater complicated to design in a stable and Get Your Assignments Done For You sturdy style. Here are some of the less obvious problems that the c# team had to deal

I have checked the whole data but I think I should not waste my time because I have to complete marketing for coursework writing service
which is the best one writing company for PhD students

Hi! Our college papers writers do advise you to give us as long as possible where you can though. Not only will this work out cheaper for you, but we also offer fourteen days for you to review your essay and request any changes. We know that many students are on a tight budget, and we do our very best to make our essay writing services as cheap as we can. We believe in providing good value for money to all of our customers.

Once you hire our professionals for your essay, you always assured we would provide your essay according do my paper to the deadline you indicated. Our essay experts are experienced in working fast and still finding success in producing the desired standards of that essay assignment.

Undeniably, the MOST adaptable present card you can purchase is a bank-gave present Birthday Gift, for example, our Visa® gift vouchers and Mastercard gift vouchers. These cards are redeemable any place Visa and Mastercard are acknowledged, and that implies they can be utilized in stores, in eateries, on the web and via telephone at traders of all shapes and sizes.

A bookkeeping services offers a three-tiered approach to developing and maintaining your company's overall financial processes and management.

On this web page, we have mentioned the PUBG Mobile MOD APK 2022 and how one can use it to play the game at a expert level. How one can attain the region with out getting behind schedule and most significantly learn how to growth the health. I could endorse using Discord to speak with other gamers.

The new Caller Info Attributes in C# 5 are a great addition to the language, allowing developers to access information about the caller of a method without having to explicitly pass the data as arguments. This feature can be used to improve code readability and maintainability, by providing more context to the code without having to clutter the signature of the method.

You updates your visual studio with 11 beta. I really love it. Keep it up. I will share with my friends. Now it's time to avail jupiter florida airport for more information.

This is also a very good post which I really enjoy reading. Do another one man Thank you for sharing this post. I am really impressed with your writing skills. I think this is one of the best article here, Thankyou
annulment vs divorce New Jersey

content is very useful.I’m glad to be here.
uncontested divorce lawyers virginia beach Beach specialize in handling divorce cases where both spouses mutually agree on all aspects of the divorce settlement and seek an amicable resolution.

The most informative blog.Alleghany Reckless DrivingThe way you descriping is too good.

Merchant Cash Advance Leads are potential customers or businesses that express interest in obtaining a merchant cash advance. These leads can originate from various sources such as online platforms, telemarketing, referrals, or direct marketing efforts. Unlike traditional loans, MCAs involve purchasing a percentage of a business's future sales at a discounted rate. Consequently, finding qualified leads that meet the criteria for a successful MCA transaction is crucial for providers.

The new Caller Info Attributes reveal a deeper level of information, enriching the caller identification process with nuanced details that help users make more informed decisions about answering or ignoring calls. These subtleties enhance communication privacy and efficiency in a dynamic digital landscape.

Estate Lawyers

The new Caller Info Attributes in C# 5 are a powerful tool for debugging and tracing code. They can be very helpful for tracking down bugs and understanding how your code is executing. However, it is important to use them sparingly to avoid adding overhead to your code.They allow you to get information about the caller of a method, including the method name, line number, and file name.
Disputa por Incumplimiento de Contrato
Disputas de Contratos Bienes Raices

"old-blog.slaks," but I don't have access to the internet to review specific websites or blogs. However, if you provide the content or specific aspects of the blog you'd like to discuss or review, I'd be happy to offer some general guidance or suggestions based on my existing knowledge up to September 2021. Please provide more details or specify what you'd like to know or discuss about the blog, and I'll do my best to assist you. How Much Are Reckless Driving Tickets in Virginia

Post a Comment